Let's say you had gotten away with it.Brian Radel: Gotten away with it? Previously city included Lake City FL. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Anchorage jurors found Waterman not guilty of 1st and 2nd degree murder, kidnapping and conspiracy to commit murder. The stories she told him about being abused by her mother only making him dream more of being the girls knight in shining armor. 30-something TBI survivor + storyteller powered by caffeine & my feline overlords https://medium.com/@fatimhemraj/membership, https://medium.com/@fatimhemraj/membership. The stories just didn't match. Judge Patricia Collins: I have concluded that that testimony, should this case proceed yet again to trial, is inadmissible. On Saturday, November 202004, Alaska State Police Trooper Robert Claus stated: During interviews all three made admissions as to their involvement in the murder. Larson: Did you guys believe at all that Lauri Waterman was hitting her with baseball bats and--. How could Rachelle Waterman's fantasies spiral into her mom's murder? Papas Pizza serves as the alternative to Dominos. Facebook gives people the power. This girl got off way too light imo. Rachelle Waterman's attorney, Steven Wells, said Monday that a state court judge granted Waterman's request earlier this month to remain free on bond, pending an appeal. View the profiles of people named Rachel Waterman. But it's not gone and forgotten with us.Don Martelli, Jr.: Im pretty bitter about it and I don't know if I can forgive her. Steve Wells, defense attorney: As you listen to this evidence, ask yourself: Is Rachelle Waterman an absolutely cold-blooded, psychotic monster? She signed an agreement to be placed into the general population. In it, Rachelle called home "Hell, Alaska." McPherron: And then after you knew what had happened --Rachelle: I told them not to do it!Sgt. Rachelle was charged with first degree murder involving the death of her mother, Lauri Waterman, in 2004. Meanwhile, Carl Waterman stood by his daughter and accused the authorities of coercing her confession. Curiously, there was no sign of forced entry. This was the first time Rachelle had heard a description of her mother's death from the killer himself the story of how he kidnapped her mother, took her to a remote logging road and then slowly killed her. John Larson reports. Alaska law places persons charged with first-degree murder at the age of 16 or older in the adult court system, and most of the records concerning this case are open to the public for inspection. She signed an agreement to be placed into the general population. Rachelle was subsequently ordered to serve three years, with credit for time served while awaiting her first trial (479 days). At one timeor still was, according to someBrian had been Rachelles boyfriend. Wells: Did Rachelle Waterman ever ask you to kill her mother?Radel: No.Wells: Did Rachelle Waterman ever tell you, I want my mom dead?Radel: No.Wells: Did she ever come to you and say, Let's figure out plans to get rid of my mom?Radel: No. The NBC series Fatal Frontier: Evil in Alaska featured a 2021 episode about the Waterman caseepisode five of season one is called "Murder on the Island." But now seemed willing to do anything to get his ex-lover convicted. And I just started - shaking. I even got to fly down the stairs, she wrote, suggesting shed been pushed and describing her then current mood as sore., Two months earlier, on April 6, 2004, Rachelle listed her mood as angry, writing, I had a bad night, and a bad day. Rachelle Waterman poured out her feelings on her blog, where she claimed her mother abused her. Don Martelli is Rachelle's grandfather. West, reading e-mail: I wish I could be with you. "No one else saw this person. As of November 2022, Rachelle's "My Crappy Life" blog, the one that started it all, is still active on LiveJournal. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. And while most entries could be brushed off as typical teenage posturing, others were more disturbing: passages on the occult, a description of a pentagram Rachelle had burned into her skin with a heated paperclip. While the 16-year-old admitted shed lied about the sexual relationship between her and Jason, omitted facts about telephone conversations between them, and had downplayed the familial conflicts while perhaps exaggerating the physical abuse, she refused to cop to murder. I won't have computer acess [sic] until the weekend or so because the police took my computer to go through the hard drive. It was disgusting," Merritt told producers. Both men confessed that they were involved in Lauris murder. 'People Magazine Investigates': Who Killed Arizona College Student Adrienne Salinas? Other than sporadic employment, Brian roamed aimlessly, living in the moment. One Waterman killer won't testify in daughter's murder retrial Radel: I felt pressured that I needed to protect Rachelle. The Appeals court conceded in its decision, which was released Friday, that there is a scientific basis for the appeal. The foreman voted not guilty. So she asked her 25-year-old boyfriend to do something about it. After the failure of the latest appeal, the three-year jail sentence stood. People in the small Alaskan village of Craig were shocked by the brutal murder of Lauri Waterman and the arrest of two young locals who quickly confessed to the killing. 30 minutes into a police interrogation, she confessed. ' And she just kept repeating that, Can I ask a question? Jason asked me, What do you think she wants to ask? And I said, I think she wants to know why in the world this is happening.. Previously, Radel had gone to shoot Lauri as she exited from the school but had to call it off after noticing he had forgotten the bolt for his rifle. Those who knew Lauri insisted she would never hurt her daughter and that Rachelle was simply enraged over her disapproval understandably, Lauri didnt like the fact that the teen was in a relationship with a 24-year-old man. Eventually, however, police elicited a confession from Jason. During the interview, she claimed she didn't encourage them to murder her mother. So its no real surprise to anyone that these two rambling men would be pals. Claus decided to question the two. She threatened me while going like this with a knife. Honor student plotted mother's murder, police say, People flock to online journal after 16-year-old's arraignment. Corrections Deputy Commissioner Portia Parker indicated that Waterman "is an adult in the eyes of the law.". It would likely mean there would be a re-trial. To get a better understanding of Lauri and her familys life, you must first know about where they lived. I don't really know how to kill somebody. A retrial was held in 2011, and she was only convicted of criminally negligent homicide and sentenced to three years in prison. Doc was a decorated serviceman who had met Lauri in Utah. But as investigators inspected the scene, they found no sign of a driver who would have been in the front seat. She was also a member of the Academic Decathlon team (ACDC) and sang in the choir, a profile that has left many people questioning her involvement in the killing and asking what motive there might be. He said Radel was the murderer, and had done it because Rachelle was being physically abused by Lauri. Don Pierce, friend of the Waterman family: Something she said triggered such strong emotions in Jason that he felt that he had to save her. Rachelle has since been released from prison and left Alaska behind. So Lauri climbed into bed sometime after eleven p.m. and went to sleep, alone. Setting up an account with the free blog platform LiveJournal, Rachelle gave it a name that left nothing to the imagination about its content: "My Crappy Life." Ill receive a small commission if you become a member with my referral link. February 6, 2015. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. /1. After that trial ended due to a hung jury, Jason Arrant refused to testify in the subsequent retrial. McPherron: Well, you don't need to be a smart aleck with me.Rachelle: Well, you don't need to question everything I say then. And an hour into her questioning, Rachelle's story and her attitude began to change. Readers are closely scrutinizing Rachelle's online journal for clues. She lives in Florida and continues to run her blog, My Crappy Life where she touts Covid-19 conspiracies. I don't think I can answer that.Larson: What do you think your mom would want you to do with regards to your sister?Geoffrey Waterman: Love her. The day after police confirmed Lauri Waterman had been murdered, Rachelle's blog ended with an emotionless entry: 11/18/04 blog entryJust to let everyone know, my mother was murdered. He was also Rachelles boyfriend. I live with my hubby & our two adorable fur babies. ET) on Investigation Discovery. Larson: Guys in the back? Breaking her neck, I definitely wasn't successful at that. Alaska Court of Appeals Denies Rachelle Waterman Appeal Both claimed that Rachelle was not only involved in the crime but had orchestrated it. And he was willing to do anything to keep her. After checking with neighbors, Carl learned that Lauri had skipped church that morning. To a continental U.S. urbanized mother, a daughters obsession with black clothing and piercings is usually viewed as a freedom of expression of ones self, but in snowy-white Craig, Alaska, a goth sticks out like a snowman on the 101 Freeway in Los Angeles. Corrections Deputy Commissioner Portia Parker indicated that Waterman "is an adult in the eyes of the law." But Rachelle says that Jason kept pressing the issue -- even ran through murder scenarios with Brian, but says she never really took them seriously. Jason, however, wasnt as strong. Brian and Jason both testified in Rachelle's trial. No motive for the crime has been suggested. Mostly sunny skies. 00:00 Rachelle Waterman was 16 when her two boyfriends beat her mother to death and framed the murder to look like a car wreck. Her youngest, Rachelle, was participating in a high school volleyball tournament in Anchorage. But she is absolutely a sociopath. This page was last edited on 15 December 2022, at 02:16. Her husband, Carl Doc Waterman, was away on business. The only difference was she lived in a place many would say is the end of the earth; a place too small to offer resources for parents dealing with adolescent challengesissues that undoubtedly stemmed from boredom. Additional charges of solicitation, conspiracy, tampering with physical evidence and other charges are pending. She went willingly, without her father or a lawyer, and with a camera rolling, Rachelle tells them she had nothing to do with the murder but does acknowledge that she had been fighting with her mom about her clothes, her interest in the occult, and her boyfriends. In February 2011, Rachelle Waterman made her first return to Craig, Alaska since her original trial for a second trial on charges she conspired to kill her mother. And the prosecution played its trump card, Rachelle's taped interrogations, which they said proved she was involved in the plot. Arrant: She said that she thought it would be better if her mother wasn't around anymore.Steven West, prosecutor: Did you ask her what she meant by that?Jason Arrant: Oh, yes.West: And what was her response?Arrant: That she thought it would be better if her mother was dead. And I mean if she said, Yes, I did it. I don't even know if I would put a lot of weight on it just because through the whole thing she stuck with "no.". Her mom, Lauri, was a special education teachers aide who volunteered with her church and other civic groups. Jason Arrant also pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and was awarded a maximum of 50 years in prison with parole eligibility just after 16 years. McPherron: Okay.Rachelle: First of all, I'd like to apologize for being a smart ass.Sgt. How Rachelle Waterman's Rebellion Led to Mom Lauri's Alaska Murder - People Prosecutors painted the picture of a troubled teen who manipulated two older men into committing murder. Lauri was loved and respected in her small town, often referred to as a "saint" by most of the people who knew her. Other strange aspects of the scene told authorities the car hadn't crashed, but had instead been set on fire. I recommend it. They would struggle with that very question for five days. He frantically called the police and reported her missing. Clark also appointed a public defender to represent Rachelle, who was sent to the Juneau Department of Corrections facility. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Wells: If she wanted her mom dead, wouldn't it have been easier if she gave you a key?Arrant: It would have been easier, yes. She was convicted of criminally negligent homicide, and sentenced to three years in prison. Police then asked him if he would wear a wire to help gather evidence on his friend and the plan worked. When you visit this site, it may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Don Pierce, friend of the Waterman family: As painful as the loss of Lauri was, I think that the arrest of his daughter was even harder. Rachelle Waterman is currently incarcerated at the Lemon Creek correctional facility, in Alaska. Investigators quickly became suspicious of Rachelle. But they didn't think a judge would grant her request. Demars: They didn't give her any room to talk.Jones: For a 15-year-old who's scared out of her mind, they're professionals. Rachelle tells the troopers she talked to the two men about seeking emancipation -- the legal equivalent of divorcing her parents. What happened down this road took all the natural beauty and solitude of the place and overnight made it seem ominous. Low 42F. Prosecutor Steven West would try to prove that she not only wanted her mother Lauri Waterman dead but with the cooperation of two former boyfriends -- helped plot the murder. Hi, Im a 30-something true crime writer & storyteller. But the next morning, a Monday, there was still no sign of Lauri. Rachelle appealed on the basis that a 16-year-old should not have been judged as an adult. Her remains were so badly burned that only a skull was immediately recognizable. She said, Can I ask a question? I said, What is it? and she kept repeating, Can I ask a question?. "I knew Rachelle had changed dramatically in her appearance and behavior in the past year, including hanging out with scary-looking guys and they were Jason Arrant and Brian Radel," Claus, who was friendly with the Watermans, told producers. High 53F. Her daughter Rachelle an honor student and athlete at the local high school was 400 miles away in Anchorage, playing in a volleyball tournament. Rachelle Waterman, now 22, is on trial, accused of plotting with the men to kill her mother. When addressing the court b4 her sentencing, all she talked about was how hard things would be for her, since she wouldn't have her mother present for her future graduation, marriage, motherhood etc! Shelter Cove Lodge offers the islands fine dining. "It's pretty gruesome what happened to her,"Randy McPherron, a retired sergeant with Alaska State Troopers, told producers. Dr. Beyer: They can't think like an adult because they don't have an adult brain. Jason Arrant was one of a handful of Craigs youth who didnt seem to break free. Both men also said that the murder was not the first attempt they made on Lauris life. He's like the biggest sucker of all time.Demars: Totally. Her husband "Doc" was out of town. I thought the worst they could ever do is talk to her. Dina Keyt, Rachelle Watermans aunt: It's not possible.Larson: Its like this family's suffering enough-- now youve got to drag somebody else into it.Dina Keyt: Yeah. Most of the jury was convinced Rachelle's tales of abuse had triggered the killing, and that she even knew her two friends were plotting murder, but weren't sure there was anything more to it than that. Rachelle Waterman faced up to 99 years in prison if convicted in her mother's murder. After all, the pickings are slim. Rachelle Waterman was 16 when her two boyfriends beat her mother to death and framed the murder to look like a car wreck. Don Martelli, Sr.: If she'd own up to it, say, Im very, very sorry this happened, should never have happened, Id feel a lot better about it. Eventually, though, she finally confessed and admitted the abuse was "pretty much lies," Claus said. Lingit Aani Kaa Kei Nas.ax Haa Yoo Xatangi. But the most dramatic testimony in the trial came when prosecutor west called to the stand the other killer -- Brian Radel. For more on this case and others like it, watch"Fatal Frontier: Evil In Alaska," airing Sundays at 7/6c on Oxygenor stream episodes here. Lauri Waterman Killed After Daughter Rachelle Asked Friends | Crime News Rachelle Waterman's attorney, Steven Wells, said Monday that a state court judge granted Waterman's request earlier this month to remain free on bond, pending an appeal. Judge Patricia Collins: The indictment must also be dismissed. And so Rachelle was released from jail to her father's open arms. Its not surprising Lauri was not thrilled with this being her daughters boyfriend a guy who is nearly a decade older, who doesnt seem to have any real goals for the rest of his life, Coyne says. The jury took one week in its deliberations and returned with not guilty verdicts on first degree murder, kidnapping, burglary and attempted murder, and guilty of criminally negligent homicide. This appeal failed because of legislative mandates that say after a persons 20th birthday, that person must be charged in adult court, even if they were only 16 at the time of the crime. When the other sergeant re-enters the room, Rachelle's attitude changes again. Protect Rachelle? Her dad, Carl Doc Waterman, was a a real estate agent and president of the school board in small-town Craig, Alaska. And with a letter Rachelle wrote to Jason, the prosecutor tried to demonstrate how Rachelle, heartless and calculating, fantasized how things might be after her mother's death. Investigators first turned to Doc as a potential suspect, as there were rumors he'd had affairs. Rachelle wrote that Lauri beat her with a baseball bat, pushed her down the stairs, body-shamed her, and forced her to go on a strict diet. I'm glad those guys are in jail, but she should be too. TV-14 Reality and Game Show Daytime Web Exclusive Go to show page Doc searched the town and then called police. Fairfield University student Mark Steven Fisher was looking for a fun night out in Manhattan with friends, but he had a little too much to drink, met a girl he liked, and followed her to a deadly party. Though, Brian Radel took the stand again in her 2011 retrial and helped the jury find Rachelle guilty of criminally negligent homicide. One name kept coming to the forefront: Jason Alan Arrant. Low 29F. A lot of the ramblings and rantings on the blog are pretty typical teenage girl stuff, PEOPLE Executive Editor Kate Coyne explains on Mondays PMI episode. And when investigators examined the evidence -- the heat of the fire, the location of the remains, the trail of gasoline leading from the vehicle, it was clear that this was no accident. Arrant was then brought in for further questioning, finally admitting his full involvement. Radel: I said "I'd protect Rachelle. A for Brian, who says he went along with Jason's plan without even asking Rachelle if - in fact - she wanted her mother murdered Larson: So Brian, you believe, really was just being played. Lauri Waterman. As for Brian Radel, he has a lot of time to think. There was hardly a soul on the island that hadnt given a juicy tidbit of gossip in an effort to catch a killer. They then considered whether their daughter, Rachelle, had any connection to the crime. her aunt Dina. But, you know, behind closed doors, other things happen. Arrant and Radel pleaded guilty to murder and testified against Rachelle. Pierce: Rachelle was just totally in tears. . Watermans lawyer, Steven Wells, says they tried to appeal the verdict, arguing that the trial shouldve been in juvenile court. After questioning Rachelle for hours again, she begrudgingly answered in the affirmative when police asked if she expected her mother to be dead by the time she arrived home from her Anchorage trip. This page is archived, and is no longer publicly editable. AK v. WATERMAN (2006) 16-year-old Rachelle Waterman is accused of plotting with her two ex-boyfriends to kill her mother. ), KTUU reported that Magestro "blames violent movies, TV shows and videogames for desensitizing young people, making them unable to understand the consequences -- or even the reality -- of their actions.". And Doc had an alibi. Rachel Payne Waterman. If convicted, she was looking at a prison term of 99 years. Rochelle Waterman. Rachelle Waterman Claimed Her Mother Abused Her - NBC Every chance Rachelle had, she was with Jason hanging out in the bookstore or sharing a pizza; never really trying to hide being in his company, and going through a vicious cycle of groundings and restrictions and groundings again. The car was also taken in and identified as the Watermans' vehicle. It was Saturday, November 13th. There they left Lauri unconscious in the vehicle and set it moving unmanned. Now, with her father standing by her, Rachelle would face the prosecutor and her mother's killers. Soon, though, he admitted she had asked him and Radel to murder Lauri. Pierce: I don't think that any of us really knew Jason. Now, more than ever, the world needs trustworthy reportingbut good journalism isnt free. Borough-wide tobacco tax indefinitely postponed, Mission Statement/Financial Statement/Code of Integrity/Diversity Statement, https://www.krbd.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/18-Waterman_Correction1.mp3. Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. The person posting who is allegedly Rachelle Waterman seems to live in Florida and espouse right-wing and Republican ideology. But told him the weekend to do it. Brian Radel: Somebody ended up dead in this story. Rachelle Waterman's 60-year-old father, Carl "Doc" Waterman, is a real estate agent and serves as president of the Craig School Board. We let Rachelle down.Blackwell: You know, I felt defeated. Richelle Waterman. McPherron: You knew it was gonna happen, and you didn't do anything --Rachelle: I told them not to do it!Sgt. Arrant was a janitor and a Marine Corps dropout. The next day, her charred body was located in a cars back seat in a remote area on Prince of Wales Island. This time the jury acquitted Rachelle of murder but found her guilty of criminally negligent homicide. After Rachelles arrest, the judge decided that Rachelle should be moved to Juneau for a fair trial. The authorities found the fingertip of a rubber glove on the floor of the master bedroom and an empty bottle of wine in the kitchen odd considering Lauri barely drank. And, about 20 minutes after the questioning began, police seem to turn up the pressure when they ask: why would she have told kids at school that her mother probably died in a drunk driving accident if she was not in on the plan? Rachelle Waterman and the plan to end her mother. - YouTube In the summer before the murder, Rachelle took up a job at a local computer store. (Don't get me wrong, the others that were convicted deserved everything they got). See Photos. Radel shaved his entire body to avoid leaving evidence behind. She appeared to be a normal, high-achieving junior in high school. JUNEAU, Alaska - An Alaska woman convicted of criminally negligent homicide in the death of her mother will not be reporting to jail to begin her sentence Friday. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. And after an hour and a half of interrogation, she tells them a new story. Two men are serving long prison sentences for their roles in Lauri Waterman's death. After binding her arms, they led her to the kitchen where they forced her to drink an entire bottle of wine, since a final act of the murder was to make it appear to be a drunken driving accident. She was also a rebellious teen who ran a blog titled My Crappy Life where she referred to her mother as a psycho b*tch and the female parental unit.. Rachelle was then released on reduced bail. Brian Radel, dated Rachelle Waterman: She would mention that her mom had hit her with a baseball bat, that her mom liked to hit her in the lower back. The Murder of Lauri Waterman - Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast Some were pure fantasy, some talked of getting married. But who would kill one of the most-loved people in town? And then Rachelle heard the rumors spreading like fire through the high school rumors that a van was found in the woods with human remains inside.